Saturday, July 12, 2008

Pioneers on the Niagara Frontier

A view of historic Fort Niagara

When the Shaws of Scotland and Ireland first arrived at Niagara Falls, they lived in a world sharply different from our own. The jagged cliffs, thundering waters and rolling hills surrounding Fort Niagara strongly resembled the wilderness described by James Fenimore Cooper in his novel The Last of the Mohicans. The Niagara frontier was an endless canopy of trees -- a sunlit wood of startling beauty haunted by murderous Mohawks, brutish Redcoats, and fierce French couriers du bois. Except for a few small settlements and log cabins, the Niagara region remained largely unpopulated, and the military situation was extremely tense.

The Shaws arrived in waves, many of them as soldiers who fought near Fort Niagara in the French and Indian Wars, the American Revolution, and the War of 1812. The name of Shaw may be found not only amongst the lists of American patriots, but also amongst the lists of United Empire Loyalists and Rangers who fought for King George, later settling on the northern shores of Lake Ontario.


If the Shaw family history that follows illustrates one thing clearly, it illustrates that American and Canadian history are not so simple as the movies might have us believe. The Shaw Clan were a large family, with branches in Scotland, Ireland and England, and the clan's colorful members have shown throughout history a striking tendency to follow their own interests and personal whims, sometimes completely disregarding the neat categories into which we might like to place them.

To say, for example, that all the Irish Shaws came to Niagara during the 1840s, or that all Irish Shaws are somehow related to George Bernard Shaw, or that they all wanted to find work on the Erie Canal, is just plain wrong. What one finds, instead, is a richly textured fabric of colorful individuals woven together by fate, often working at cross-purposes, yet somehow combined into a design so rich that one might think that the Shaws were trying to weave their family history itself into a Clan tartan.

Though we who live in the 21st Century have but dim memories and photographs of our ancestors who lived in the 18th, 19th and 20th Centuries, though we may only see their shadows and silhouettes through the glass of time, still we find in these puzzling patterns and images a striking truth that speaks to the present: Life is flowing onward, ever onward. Like Niagara Falls itself, life ends, and yet it never ends.


If the author has done his job well, the perceptive reader will catch in the following pages a glimpse of more than just the memorabilia and bric-a-brac of a single Scotch-Irish family in upstate New York. One may glimpse here the "Maid in The Mist" -- the Holy Grail -- that brought so many people to America. This is not just the story of the incredible magnetic force of nature that drew so many Scots and Irish to the Niagara region. It is also a reflection on the divine madness of love that inspired so many young people of the 19th Century to take the plunge into the river of life and venture all of their hopes and dreams upon the water.

Every single one of the Shaws, and every single pioneer in American history had the courage to face an uncertain future beyond a new horizon -- which is roughly the equivalent of going over Niagara Falls in a barrel. This is the story of how the Shaws did it -- and where the river carried them.

Origins of the Clan Shaw

A clan map of Scotland during the time of Robert The Bruce:

Source: http://www.thebloodisstrong.com/maps/clan_map03.jpg

The Scotch-Irish Shaws of Niagara County, New York, claim descent from the Shaw clan of Scotland. Anyone who has read William Shakespeare's play MacBeth knows the clan's basic history, for the Shaws claim descent from Lady MacBeth, known historically as Queen Gruoch.







Descent from Lady MacBeth

As you may recall, the play MacBeth involves a bloody feud between rivals for the throne of 11th-century Scotland. The story is retold beautifully by the author Dorothy Dunnett in her novel King Hereafter which may be found at her website here:




HRH Prince Michael of Albany gives an excellent explanation for why the clans were fighting in his book The Forgotten Monarchy of Scotland: The True Story of the Royal House of Stewart and the Hidden Lineage of the Kings and Queens of Scots (New York: Element Books, 2000).

Put simply, the House of Stewart is a "Grail Family" (claiming descent from the House of David), and it descends from the rulers of Scots Dalriada, who intermarried with local Pictish tribes.
Because the Pictish clans allowed inheritance through the mother's lineage, "it was necessary to devise a system of succession which would suit the Pictish nation as well as the Scots. It was decided that Pictish princesses would marry [the king's] sons and grandsons, with the proviso that new monarchs would be chosen from their various offspring during the lifetime of each reigning king." (p. 20)




The result was intense rivalry among the cousins of the royal family, and all hell broke loose when King Malcolm II tried to demolish the Tanist system by killing off his rivals. Gruoch, the heiress of Duff (Dubh), was a granddaughter to King Kenneth III, and had a very strong claim to the throne under the ancient laws of Tanist succession.

The story of MacBeth was therefore the story of a blood feud between rival princes over who would win Queen Gruoch's hand in marriage, and the throne of Scotland with it. MacBeth lost, and King Malcolm III won.
More importantly, the story of MacBeth was the story of an ongoing fight: A battle royale between the Celtic Church (which claims ancient apostolic succession) and the Church of Rome, which backed Malcolm III and the Anglo-Saxon tradition of patrilineal succession.
Surprisingly, Dunnett and many revisionist historians now view MacBeth as one of Scotland's better kings, and the rightful heir to the Celtic throne, not a villain. In terms of succession, his claim to the throne was strong indeed, and in the eyes of many, he fought an heroic battle to protect and defend an ancient Celtic tradition of choosing the king "democratically" from amongst the royal clan's best candidates.

Dunnett portrays MacBeth's relationship to Queen Gruoch as a tragic love story which ended in disaster, with King MacBeth's execution and Queen Gruoch's forced marriage to Malcolm III, who usurped succession to the throne to his own lineage in perpetuity.

For the Shaw clan, who are descendants of both Lady MacBeth and Malcolm III, the death of MacBeth was a mixed blessing.  Certainly it was a key event that launched their career in the annals of Scottish nobility.

Descent from King Malcolm III and the Thanes of Fife

The Shaw Clan claims descent from Aedh, the First Earl or Thane of Fife, eldest son of King Malcolm III and Queen Gruoch. Since the Royal House of Stewart descends through a parallel line (King Malcolm remarried to a Saxon princess), one could view the Shaws as a collateral branch of the House of Stewart. Certainly the Shaw lands were next to the lands of Clan Stewart, as seen on the Clan map above.

For an overview of the family trees involved, I would highly recommend The Mammoth Book of Kings and Queens by Mike Ashley (New York: Carol & Graf Publishers, 1998). See especially Chart 20 - Kings of the Scots: House of Dunkeld, and Chart 21 - Kings of the Scots: Malcolm III to Margaret, on pages 396 to 397.
For political reasons, Aedh or Aethelred does not always appear in the genealogies of Malcolm III, whose children by his second (Saxon) queen, Margaret, are much more clearly documented. Nevertheless, Aedh's pedigree may be found online. Perhaps the best historical summary is here:
Earls of Fife and the Culdee Church
As the author at the link above explains, Aedh or Aethelred MacMalcolm "was made hereditary Abbott of Dunkeld, and because of his important ecclesiastical position, was barred from the throne. (His younger brothers were Kings Alexander I and King David I.) In the Celtic "Culdee" Church (a gentle blend of Christian and Druidic tradition) priests were allowed to marry and to pass on their religious duties down through their family lines."
Aedh married the sister and heiress of Mael Snechta, the King of Moray and Chief of Clan Duff. By this wife he had two sons, Ghillemichael and Constantine MacDuff. After several uprisings and rebellions, Ghillemichael's son Duncan, the 5th Thane or Earl of Fife, became the regent of Scotland in 1153.
The Clan MacIntosh and Clan Shaw trace descent from Duncan's second son, Shaw MacDuff.

Origin of the Shaw Name: Mhic an Toiseach

The Shaw clan takes its name from Shaw MacDuff. Shaw was made keeper of the royal castle of Inverness and his heirs became known as the 'Mhic an Toiseach' (MacIntosh) or the 'sons of the Thane'. The gaelic word "Toiseach" sounds like "Shaw" - hence the claim that Shaws descend from the Clan MacIntosh, the 'sons of the Thane.'

http://www.scotclans.com/scottish_clans/clans/shaw/history.html


Early Lineage of the Highland Shaws

The lineage of the Clan Shaw spans many hundreds of years. Here's a brief overview:
http://www.theclanshaw.org/summary.html

For a map of Clan Shaw territory in 11th Century Scotland, follow this link: http://www.theclanshaw.org/maps.html

See also: http://www.scotclans.com/scottish_clans/clans/shaw/history.html





Note the claim that the Shaw name originates from the Gaelic word seaghdha ("Pitiful"). This is pure speculation. One might just as easily claim that the name Shaw derives from the gaelic word for "wolf" (sitheach). The present author prefers the explanation given above, which indicates the Shaws descend from the MacIntosh clan, the "sons of the Thane" (toisheach).


Lineage of the Lowland Shaws

An excellent source for Shaw Lineage may be found at this page: http://www.thepeerage.com/i1522.htm#s28873


The Shaws of Ireland

"The Shaws of Clan Eire typically consider themselves of Rothiemurchus stock," according to the editor of clanshaw.org. Burke's Peerage indicates the Shaws of Ireland may be divided into the following geographic groups:

The Shaws of Clonmel and Cork
The Shaws of Sandpits (including the family of George Bernard Shaw)
The Shaws of Dublin and the Baronetage of Bushy Park
http://www.thepeerage.com/p26088.htm#i260875

Thundergate: Fort Niagara and Its Role on the New Frontier

Fort Niagara played an extremely important role in three wars: The French and Indian War, the American Revolution, and The War of 1812.

Early Shaws Near Ft. Niagara 1700 - 1750

The name of Shaw appears among the earliest settlers of the Niagara region. Here's a brief list.

Shaws Near Niagara during the French and Indian War

Among the soldiers who fought for Britain during the French and Indian Wars (1754) were several named Shaw. The following list gives an overview of the most prominent Shaws, with a special emphasis on those stationed near Fort Niagara between 1750 and 1775.

Land Grants to Shaws in The Queen's Rangers and Other Loyalist Units

After the war, the British aggressively pursued the settlement of the lands along the Canadian border in order to prevent the Americans from moving further north. Toward this end, they rewarded those soldiers who had fought in Loyalist units by granting them large tracts of land, and they encouraged the citizens of Britain, Scotland and Ireland to move to Canada with their families.

The region around Fort Niagara was of special concern to the British commanders, and they placed a premium on getting that area settled. Given the overpopulation of Ireland in the early 1800s, and the growing unrest there, it made sense to move as many Irish as possible to Canada.

The net result was an explosion of Irish and Scottish settlers in the Niagara region, and several families among the new arrivals were named Shaw. The soldiers who were granted lands in Upper Canada are especially well documented by government records. A brief summary follows.

Gen. Aeneas Shaw and the Settlement of Ontario

Many Scottish members of the Shaw family traveled to Ontario to be near one of the chiefs of their clan, Gen. Aeneas Shaw, a military commander who played a key role in the settlement of Upper Canada.